Christopher Balding (“Not China Naive Balding”) explains why it matters, a lot, whether the arrested Huawei CFO Wanzhou Meng entered Canada on a Canadian passport, as has been rumored:
Here is what people don’t know about the dual passport situation with regards to Chinese citizens. You may ask, why would the CFO of Huawei enter Canada under a Canadian passport? There are very clear reasons and I absolute no doubt about it guarantee every Chinese 1/n
citizen with two passports knows what I am about to tell you. The simplest answer is that if you enter another country using a non-Chinese passport it is a lot easier, typically you don’t need a visa. That may be part of it but that isn’t the primary reason. 2/n
The primary reason, and let me reiterate, every Chinese I have ever met with two passports knows this, when you enter a country, which ever country passport you enter the country is what nationality the accepting country recognizes. In other words, when she entered Canada 3/n
with a Canadian passport, if that is in fact what she did, she is recognized as a Canadian citizen. If she enters France/Japan/China with a Canadian passport, she is recognized as a Canadian citizen by international law. Why does that matter you ask? If you ever get 4/n
into trouble, the only country the host country allows you to get consular or other access to is your country of citizenship. Most “Chinese” with second passports enter China using Canadian/US/Australian passports even if they have Chinese passports for this exact reason. 5/n
When Chinese with second passports travel abroad, they use the second passport not just because of the visa ease issue, but because they prefer being represented by actual humane governments. So when she entered Canada on a Canadian passport, if she did, 6/n
She was telling you, and I absolutely guarantee she knew what I’m telling you, she would rather be represented by Canada than by China. She could get a visa no problem and enter with her Chinese passport. Let me put it another way, Chinese with means are making clear 7/n
And conscious choice who they want representing them if they get jammed up, and it is rarely China. In her case, that may not be the best choice. However, I absolutely guarantee you every Chinese with two passports knows this and chooses this way. Done
1:32 AM – 7 Dec 2018
And a BBC reporter comments:
We did ask the #China Foreign Ministry yesterday if Meng Wanzhou had entered #Canada on a Chinese or Canadian passport but no response.
1:30 AM – 7 Dec 2018
High probability: Huawei CFO not arrested directly for Huawei activities but for running transactions through closely held separate independent Cayman SPV which she runs that channeled FX transactions and profits through NYC. If that is the case, she is screwed
3:19 AM – 7 Dec 2018
This is also interesting:
China has said it will immediately implement measures agreed under a trade war “truce” with the US.
The commerce ministry’s remarks came days after Donald Trump and his Chinese counterpart, Xi Jinping, agreed to give negotiators 90 days to resolve their trade spat.
Few details have been made public about what the two sides will negotiate, a lack of clarity that has unsettled stock markets.
“China will immediately implement the consensus both sides already reached on agricultural products, energy, autos and other specific items,” a commerce ministry spokesman, Gao Feng, said at a regular press briefing. […]
Gao’s briefing came hours after the trade detente risked being rattled by the arrest in Canada of a top executive from the Chinese telecom giant Huawei at the request of the US.
Hmmm. Clearly, there is a *lot* more going on here than meets the eye. As usual, it’s stupid to rush to judgment before the facts are revealed (a thing I am definitely guilty of).